You were backing out of your garage on your own property, but didn't look in your rearview mirror and you ran over a kid or another person. Would it be your fault? Because, technically, he shouldn't have been on YOUR property in the first place, right?
NEW Welcome Ad
Collapse
Leader
Collapse
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Would you get into trouble if...
Collapse
300x250 Mobile
Collapse
X
-
Good luck arguing that one at the civil trial. It all depends on how you backed out of the garage. If you slammed on the gas and flew out of there, then yes, you could be at fault.
There are too many variables, such as, the size of your lot, most people expect someone to walk across their yard/driveway from time to time (paperboy, mailman, gas meter reader etc) Unless your property is surrounded by a very high security fence, any one can walk in that area.
I say this assuming you are speaking of an average size suburban lot.
-
You worry about really wierd stuff,
It is your responsibility to make sure that you do not run over people with a car, and if you live in California you would probably be responsible if a guy stole you car and ran over himself with it.
Seriously it could be as bad as negligent homicide depending on the circumstances.Cum catapultae proscriptae erunt tum soli proscript catapultas habebunt.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Capn CircusYou were backing out of your garage on your own property, but didn't look in your rearview mirror and you ran over a kid or another person. Would it be your fault? Because, technically, he shouldn't have been on YOUR property in the first place, right?
Comment
-
Originally posted by Capn CircusYou were backing out of your garage on your own property, but didn't look in your rearview mirror and you ran over a kid or another person. Would it be your fault? Because, technically, he shouldn't have been on YOUR property in the first place, right?When I'll be the girl that you love, you'll be the boy that I hate...
Comment
-
Yes it would be your fault.
The driveway like the sidewalk is a public access point to the property and you would not be able to argue that the person does not belong there.
If that were the case I have a brother in law I would have backed over years ago and pulled up then backed up etc etc
Comment
-
Property owners have a duties they owe to trespassers, they vary from state to state, but that would not be a good situation to be in. It all depends on the circumstances, though...
Was it possible to see the person (was it 3am in the morning or was there heavy fog/snow/rain)? Was the person in an unreasonable place (laying on the ground for instance)? Did the person cause the incident to occur (running through your property, tripping under the tire at the same instant you were backing out)?
I'm not sure what the criminal situation would be like where you live, but as far as your civil liability comparative (contributory) negligence, your fault compared to the victim's fault would be evaluated and in most states be used to determine whether or not you were liable and if so to what extent.
Lookup "duty to trespasser" "comparative negligence" or variations for more information.Last edited by ctt; 10-08-2005, 11:23 AM.
Comment
-
Regardless of blame, isn't there the duty of a driver of a motor vehicle to drive with due regard for others, be they pedestrians or motorists? Was the kid who was hit on the sidewalk so often part of one's driveway? If I were serving on a jury, taking into considration all that is taught by driving instructors as basics for driving and common sense I would have to say that safety is job one when you are behind the wheel. You are controlling a potenially deadly weapon and are expected to control it as to avoid a situation where great harm or death could occur.
What is it with folks checking to see if it is OK to drive unsafely (refering to an earlier legal help post), if ya have to ask don't do it!"A Nation without Borders is not a Nation."
- Ronald Reagan
"Every immigrant that comes here should be required, within five years, to learn English or leave the country." -Theodore Roosevelt
"Liberalism is a mental disease." - Mike Savage
Comment
-
Originally posted by BodieThe driveway like the sidewalk is a public access point to the property and you would not be able to argue that the person does not belong there.
Comment
-
Originally posted by SO535Yup. And the side walk from the driveway or street to your front door too.
Comment
-
Originally posted by SO535I can only say what the situation would be in the State Of Georgia. My academy failed to teach me Missouri law.
Does the UPS man get a license or even ask permission??
The driveway is the property owner's property, it is not public property. If the property owner tells the person to leave and they do not, the licensee or invitee becomes a trespasser. If the property owner does not know that the person is there, he can only be held liable if he knows of dangerous conditions and fails to remedy them.
You always have the duty to act with reasonable caution, regardless of whether you know there are others on your property. It's not a black and white issue of "you in car + pedestrian = you are at fault."
Uh oh, we found the "what if" guy.Last edited by ctt; 10-09-2005, 05:49 PM.
Comment
MR300x250 Tablet
Collapse
What's Going On
Collapse
There are currently 3129 users online. 184 members and 2945 guests.
Most users ever online was 158,966 at 05:57 AM on 01-16-2021.
Tag Cloud
Collapse
Welcome Ad
Collapse
Comment