Leader

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Appeals court reverses release of Guantanamo Bay detainee

Collapse

300x250 Mobile

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Appeals court reverses release of Guantanamo Bay detainee

    March 29, 2011

    U.S. appeals court judges rejected a Guantanamo Bay detainee's defense on Tuesday because they found it unlikely that he was an innocent who repeatedly just happened to find himself at hot spots where the United States was engaged against al-Qaida.

    Uthman Abdul Rahim Mohammed Uthman of Yemen had won a lower court decision granting his release after more than nine years at the U.S. naval prison in Cuba for terror suspects. A three-judge appellate panel overturned that ruling Tuesday.

    Uthman says he was mistaken as an al-Qaida fighter fleeing U.S. bombardment of Tora Bora when he was captured at the Afghan-Pakistani border in December 2001. The U.S. government says Uthman was among Osama bin Laden's bodyguards and fought against anti-Taliban forces. He denied both claims.

    Uthman said he went to Afghanistan to teach the Quran and was doing so in Kabul on Sept. 11, 2001. He said he fled after the United States began fighting the country's Taliban rulers, but instead of taking the more direct eastward route to Pakistan he followed his interpreter south through the mountainous region toward Tora Bora. That is where bin Laden had relocated as al-Qaida gathered for a major battle against the United States and its allies and where Uthman says he happened to meet up with some schoolmates he was later captured with.

    The school they had attended was the Furqan Institute, a religious school in Yemen where al-Qaida had recruited fighters. Among those schoolmates in Uthman's group were two admitted bin Laden bodyguards and a Taliban fighter.

    The court also found that Uthman traveled to Afghanistan along a route used by al-Qaida recruits and was seen at an al-Qaida guest house. Uthman said none of that proved he was a member of al-Qaida.

    "Uthman's account piles coincidence upon coincidence upon coincidence," the appeals court wrote. "Here, as with the liable or guilty party in any civil or criminal case, it remains possible that Uthman was innocently going about his business and just happened to show up in a variety of extraordinary places — a kind of Forrest Gump in the war against al-Qaida. But Uthman's account at best strains credulity, and the far more likely explanation for the plethora of damning circumstantial evidence is that he was part of al-Qaida."

    Forrest Gump was a movie character played by Tom Hanks who through coincidence was a part of many monumental Vietnam-era events.

    U.S. District Judge Henry Kennedy Jr. had ruled that the U.S. government did not prove that Uthman received and executed orders from al-Qaida, the so-called "command structure test." But since that ruling, the appeals court has rejected that formal standard for determining whether a detainee was part of al-Qaida and instead ordered that judges look at each detainee's actions individually to determine if he was a member of the terrorist group.

    The appeals court also found Uthman's version suspicious because he claimed he paid for his travel to Afghanistan himself primarily by working summers selling food at a roadside shack. The government argued Uthman would have had to earn more than three times the average Yemeni's annual income in only a few summers of unskilled work. The lower court found that Uthman actually received the money from a sheik, and the appeals court said the false statement was strong evidence of his guilt.

    The unanimous appeals court decision was issued by two judges, Brett Kavanaugh and Thomas Griffith, nominated by President George W. Bush, and by Judge Merrick Garland, a nominee of President Bill Clinton. Kavanaugh wrote the court's opinion.

    According to a count by the Justice Department, judges in the Washington federal court have now ordered the release of 34 detainees and ruled that 21 are being properly held. Uthman remained at Guantanamo after the release order pending appeal.

    http://www.npr.org/2011/03/29/134965...ee?ft=1&f=1001
    Facts do not cease to exist because they are ignored. -- Aldous Huxley
    Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity. -- Albert Einstein

  • #2
    Why don't we just try them in open court and find out if there is sufficient evidence to convict them? Why do we keep waiting to try them?
    Retired

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by retired View Post
      Why don't we just try them in open court and find out if there is sufficient evidence to convict them? Why do we keep waiting to try them?
      There isn't enough evidence to find them guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. But the standard is lower for detaining someone as a prisoner of war. You can hold him until the war is over. (Ha Ha!)

      It's also amusing to have Obama keep Guantanamo open to house POWs.
      Facts do not cease to exist because they are ignored. -- Aldous Huxley
      Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity. -- Albert Einstein

      Comment

      MR300x250 Tablet

      Collapse

      What's Going On

      Collapse

      There are currently 3220 users online. 212 members and 3008 guests.

      Most users ever online was 26,947 at 07:36 PM on 12-29-2019.

      Welcome Ad

      Collapse
      Working...
      X